|
|
||||||||
Dep. of Crop and Soil Sciences, Univ. of Georgia, Athens, GA 30602
* Corresponding author (wmiller{at}uga.edu).
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Abbreviations: Alp, pyrophosphate-extractable Al asl, above sea level BP, before present DSC, differential scanning calorimetry EG, ethylene glycol ET, evapotranspiration IR, infrared spectroscopy subscript [o], acid oxalate-extractable XRD, X-ray diffraction
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The formation of Alhumus complexes has been observed in recent and buried A horizons of volcanic ash soils, and has been reported to be favored by conditions unfavorable to the formation of allophane (Shoji et al., 1982; Shoji and Fujiwara, 1984). Aluminumhumus complexes are predominant at pH (H2O) <5, whereas the precipitation of allophane is favored above pH 5. It has been further suggested that the precipitation of allophane is impeded by competition between humic substances and orthosilicic acid for soluble Al (Wada, 1989; Shoji et al., 1993).
Allophane and halloysite are the dominant components in the clay fraction of many volcanic ash soils around the world. It has been suggested that halloysite forms over time upon weathering of allophane (e.g., Wada, 1989); however, many studies have revealed that volcanic ash may weather directly to halloysite as well as to allophane (e.g., Parfitt et al., 1983; Parfitt et al., 1984; Parfitt and Wilson, 1985; Singleton et al., 1989). Silicon activity in the soil solution has been suggested as the overriding factor responsible for the preferential formation of either halloysite or allophane. Parfitt and Wilson (1985) and Singleton et al. (1989) found that halloysite was predominant when H4SiO04 in soil solution exceeded 250 and 350 µmol L-1, respectively, and allophane predominated below these concentrations.
A variety of factors can control soil solution chemistry and hence affect the mineralogy of a soil's colloidal fraction. Wada (1987) has suggested that in contrast with allophane, the formation of halloysite is favored by a thick depositional overburden that produces a silica-rich environment. Singleton et al. (1989) and Bakker et al. (1996) reported impeded drainage to favor halloysite formation, whereas the presence of allophane was associated with well-drained soil horizons. Parfitt et al. (1983) proposed a weathering scheme for rhyolitic ash, in which halloysite is the dominant clay mineral where the mean annual precipitation is less than approximately 1500 mm, and allophane predominates above 1500 mm. Along these lines, many subsequent studies on volcanic ash soils in different parts of the world have confirmed the importance of rainfall and leaching in mineral formation (e.g., Parfitt et al., 1984; Stevens and Vucetich, 1985; Takahashi et al., 1993; Nizeyimana et al., 1997; Nieuwenhuyse et al., 2000).
Toposequences of soils along the slopes of volcanoes have been studied to assess the effect of climate on weathering and mineral formation (Chartres and Pain, 1984; Nizeyimana et al., 1997). On an extinct volcano in Rwanda, Nizeyimana et al. (1997) found decreasing allophane contents and increasing halloysite contents with decreasing elevation, which they attributed to a concomitant decrease in rainfall. Chartres and Pain (1984) found a similar weathering pattern with elevation in highland Papua New Guinea, although there precipitation increased with decreasing elevation. They suggested that lower rates of evapotranspiration with increasing altitude caused greater leaching, thus favoring the formation of allophane.
In addition to allophane and halloysite, 2:1-type phyllosilicates with and without hydroxy-Al interlayering are commonly found in volcanic ash soils. Their occurrence has been ascribed to in situ pedogenic transformations (Shoji et al., 1982; Yamada and Shoji, 1983), eolian addition (Mizota and Takahashi, 1982; Mizota, 1983), incorporation into volcanic ash during eruption (Dudas and Harward, 1975; Pevear et al., 1982; Ping et al., 1988), and mixing of recent volcanic ash with underlying paleosols (Dudas and Harward, 1975).
The above discussion suggests that similar trends in weathering and development of volcanic ash soils exist in different parts of the world. However, specific environmental conditions, such as the eruption histories of surrounding volcanoes, the composition of volcanic ejecta, present-day climate, as well as paleoclimate and glaciation history, result in a unique combination of factors and processes governing soil formation at a given location. The pedogenesis of volcanic ash soils has been extensively studied in Japan and New Zealand; however, very little is known about weathering and soil formation on the slopes of volcanic peaks in the Andes. The objective of this study was, therefore, to investigate the factors and processes that affect soil development on volcanic slopes in the unique inter-Andean valley of northern Ecuador.
| MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
Dissolution analyses were conducted according to Wada (1989). Aluminum associated with soil organic matter, Alp, was estimated by extraction with 0.1 M sodium pyrophosphate at pH 10 using a soil/solution ratio of 1:100 and shaking for 16 h. Aluminum and silicon associated with active amorphous constituents, Alo and Sio, respectively, were estimated by extraction of ground (<0.25 mm) samples with 0.175 M ammonium oxalateoxalic acid at pH 3 using a soil/solution ratio of 1:100 and shaking for 4 h in the dark. Aluminum and silicon were measured by inductively coupled plasmamass spectrometry (ICP-MS). The molar Al/Si ratio of allophane was calculated from (Alo - Alp)/Sio, and the amount of allophane in the samples was estimated by multiplying Sio by 5, 6, 7, or 10 if the Al/Si ratio was approximately 1, 1.5, 2, or 2.5, respectively (Parfitt, 1990).
For mineralogical analyses, the clay fraction (<2 µm) was separated from the soil samples by repeated dispersion and centrifugation after initial dispersion with ultrasonic vibration (Hunter and Busacca, 1989). The clay samples were analyzed with differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) at temperatures between 35 and 600°C and infrared (IR) spectroscopy at wavenumbers between 400 and 4000 cm-1. Oriented clay samples were prepared for X-ray diffraction (XRD) analysis using the filter-membrane technique (Drever, 1973) with the following saturation treatments: Mg saturation, air-dried, and ethylene glycol solvated; K saturation, air-dried, and heated to 110, 300, and 550°C. The samples were scanned from 3 to 32 °2
with CuK
1,2 radiation and a curved crystal monochromator.
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
Organic C contents of both recent and buried A horizons increase with altitude. Given the same age of the recent parent materials, average C sequestration rates appear to be an order of magnitude higher in high-elevation pedons compared with low-elevation pedons. Soil pH (H2O) values decrease with increasing elevation, and are generally lower in recent A horizons than in underlying soil horizons including buried A horizons. In all the studied pedons, pH (KCl) is consistently lower than pH (H2O), indicating exchangeable acidity in these soils.
Amorphous Colloidal Constituents
The results of the dissolution analyses and properties related to amorphous material are presented in Table 3. In pedons at elevations above 3200 m asl, pH (NaF) values are generally above 9.4 in the entire profile, that is, in recent soils and underlying paleosols. This indicates the dominant presence of active Al-OH groups in the exchange complex of these soils (Wada, 1980). In pedons between 3200 and 2700 m asl, pH (NaF) values are above 9.4 only in the upper horizons, and in pedons below 2700 m asl, pH (NaF) values are below 9.4 in all horizons. Phosphate retention shows similar trends as pH (NaF) with the highest values in high-elevation pedons, high values in the upper horizons of pedons at intermediate elevations, and low values in all horizons of low-elevation pedons.
|
The molar ratios of Alp/organic C were calculated for recent and buried A horizons (Table 3). The Alp/C ratios of recent A horizons are significantly higher in pedons above 2700 m asl than in pedons below (
= 0.05), and buried A horizons generally have higher Alp/C ratios than recent A horizons. The 2Ab2 and 3Ab horizons of Pedon 10 and the 3Ab horizon of Pedon 11 exhibit particularly high Alp/C ratios (0.160.19). Aluminum appears to be bound very strongly to organic functional groups in these horizons, exceeding the extraction power of ammonium oxalateoxalic acid, which results in negative values of Alo - Alp (Table 3).
The clay fractions of the studied soils exhibit a single IR absorption maximum around 1000 cm-1 (data not shown) and show no dehydroxylation between 300 and 400°C (Fig. 2) , which rules out the presence of imogolite. Therefore, Sio is assumed to originate from allophane, although some of it may arise from incongruent dissolution of poorly ordered minerals, such as embryonic halloysite (Wada and Kakuto, 1985). In the studied soils, allophane contents increase with altitude and are highest in the three highest-elevation pedons (above 3200 m asl), where significant amounts are found in the entire profile. In pedons at intermediate elevations (32002700 m asl), allophane is found in smaller quantities and predominantly in the upper part of the profile, and in low-elevation pedons (below 2700 m asl), allophane contents are generally below 1% (Table 3).
|
1% allophane (Table 3), reveal that in recent A horizons of high-elevation pedons, the majority of active aluminol groups pertains to Alhumus complexes (Alp/Alo > 0.5), whereas in subsurface horizons including buried A horizons, the majority of active Al-OH groups appears to be associated with allophane (Alp/Alo < 0.5).
Crystalline Colloidal Constituents
Pedons 2, 3, and 4, representing a toposequence on the slopes of Cerro Huanansí (Table 1, Fig. 1), were selected to further study the mineralogy of the soil colloidal fraction at elevations ranging from 3000 to 3900 m asl. The clay fractions of C horizons from recent soils and paleosols were analyzed with DSC (Fig. 2) and XRD (Fig. 3 and 4)
.
|
|
The XRD patterns of Pedons 2 and 3 reveal that the C1 horizons of both pedons are devoid of clay minerals (Fig. 3). However, in the C2 horizons, a prominent reflection at 1.4 nm was found with Mg saturation, part of which expanded on ethylene glycol (EG) solvation. Saturation with K resulted in partial collapse of this reflection, which gradually shifted toward 1 nm on heating to 110, 300, and 550°C (Fig. 3). This indicates the presence of smectitic (and possibly vermiculitic) layers with partial hydroxy-Al interlayering. The peak at 0.7 nm is believed to correspond with the 002 reflections from the 1.4-nm phases, since the DSC data of these horizons did not indicate the presence of kaolin minerals (Fig. 2).
The C1 horizon of Pedon 4 exhibits a 1.4-nm reflection with Mg saturation that expands on EG solvation and collapses to 1 nm with K saturation, and is therefore considered to pertain to smectite (Fig. 3). The same horizon further shows a broad reflection between 0.72 and 1 nm, part of which expands to near 1.1 nm when solvated with EG. The reflection sharpens and collapses to near 0.72 nm when heated to 110 and 300°C and disappears when further heated to 550°C (Fig. 3). This is attributed to the presence of two populations of halloysite, that is, the 7 Å and the hydrated 10 Å forms, respectively. The C2 horizon of Pedon 4 shows a similar XRD pattern, indicating the presence of smectite and halloysite. However, the reflections are weaker and the collapsed halloysite peak (after heating to 110 and 300°C) is broader than in the horizon above (Fig. 3). This suggests that the crystallinity of halloysite decreases from the C1 to the underlying C2 horizon of Pedon 4.
In the paleosol, smectite was not detected; however, both 7 and 10 Å halloysite was found in Pedon 3 (Fig. 4), and only hydrated (10 Å) halloysite was found in Pedon 4 (Fig. 4). The collapsed halloysite peaks are sharper in the paleosols than in the recent soils (Fig. 3 and 4), indicating higher crystallinity in the former.
The presence of halloysite in recent soils and paleosols of pedons below 3000 m asl was further confirmed by XRD analysis (data not shown). A diffuse, broad hump above 20 °2
observed in the XRD patterns of the studied clay samples is ascribed to the presence of pyroclastic glass.
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
= 0.05) between these three zones. The observed altitudinal trends correspond with climatic differences as determined by elevation on the volcano; however, these differences are interrelated with differences in land use and vegetation. At higher elevations, higher rainfall and lower evapotranspiration (ET) caused by lower temperatures and higher humidity, result in greater leaching and less pronounced seasonal drying. As precipitation decreases and ET increases with decreasing elevation, the soils experience less leaching and a pronounced period of desiccation during the dry season. The high-leaching environment at elevations above 3200 m asl has resulted in the formation of andic soil properties, as defined by Soil Survey Staff (1998) and manifested by the dominant presence of active aluminol groups associated with allophane and Alhumus complexes as well as by high PO4 retention. High additions of organic matter from the páramo vegetation combined with slowed decomposition due to low temperatures, low pH values, and the presence of stabilizing Alhumus complexes may have caused the increased accumulation of organic C and the formation of melanic epipedons at these elevations. The soils are classified as Melanocryands and Melanudands, which due to their relatively weak development and comparatively low contents of weathering products belong to the Vitric and Pachic Vitric subgroups, respectively (Table 1). The colloidal fraction of these soils is dominated by amorphous constituents and characterized by the absence of halloysite. The predominance of Alhumus complexes over allophane in the uppermost horizons of the highest-elevation pedons is believed to be mainly a result of pH (H2O) values <5 in these horizons, which have been shown to inhibit the formation of allophane and favor that of Alhumus complexes (Shoji et al., 1982; Shoji and Fujiwara, 1984). The increased presence of organic ligands in these horizons may have further impeded the precipitation of allophane by competition with orthosilicic acid for soluble Al.
Evidence of 2:1-type phyllosilicates with partial hydroxy-Al interlayering was found in the C2 horizons of Pedons 2 and 3, whereas the overlying C1 horizons as well as the underlying C3 horizon (Pedon 2) did not contain clay minerals (Fig. 3). Since no A horizons were found in between the three tephra layers, they are considered to arise from consecutive eruptions of more or less the same age. Because of the isolated occurrence of 2:1-type phyllosilicates in only the C2 horizons, it is believed that incorporation during eruption, as reported by Dudas and Harward (1975), Pevear et al. (1982), and Ping et al. (1988), is the likely origin of the observed clay mineral association. The presence of expandable silicate layers may have counteracted the formation of allophane by competition with orthosilicic acid for hydroxy-Al polymers, thus resulting in lower allophane contents in the C2 horizons than in the C1 horizons above (Table 3).
As leaching decreases with decreasing elevation, andic soil properties become less strongly expressed and are confined to the upper horizons in pedons between 3200 and 2700 m asl, disappearing completely in pedons below 2700 m asl. Organic matter contents decrease with decreasing elevation, presumably because of less additions in cultivated land and more rapid decomposition due to higher temperatures, higher pH values, and lower amounts of stabilizing Al-humus complexes. This has resulted in the formation of umbric epipedons at intermediate elevations (32002700 m asl) and ochric epipedons containing <1% organic C at elevations below 2700 m asl. At intermediate elevations, the soils are classified as Humic Udivitrands with the exception of Pedon 4, which has andic soil properties in the A horizon, but does not meet the depth requirement for Andisols (Soil Survey Staff, 1998) and is therefore classified in the Andic subgroup of Inceptisols (Table 1). At elevations below 2700 m asl, the soils are classified as Dystrudepts in the presence, and Udorthents in the absence of a Bw horizon, all belonging to the Vitrandic subgroup due to high contents of pumice fragments and pyroclastic glass (Table 1).
Pedon 4 is located on the lower backslope of Cerro Huanansí, with Pedons 2 and 3 located close to the summit and on the middle part of the backslope, respectively, and Pedon 5 just 50 m below Pedon 4, on the upper part of a depositional fan with considerably lower slope gradient (Fig. 1). The influence of topography on pedogenesis has been shown by Chen et al. (1999), who studied a toposequence of volcanic ash soils in subtropical Taiwan and attributed thinner sola and lower topsoil organic matter contents in backslope positions to increased lateral water flow and surface runoff. The toposequence of Cerro Huanansí demonstrates the impact of topography on soil development in the area under study. While the summit pedon has two A horizons reaching to a depth of 100 cm, the topsoils are considerably shallower (40 and 30 cm) in the middle and lower backslope positions, respectively (Table 2). This is likely the result of translocation of topsoil material downslope, which has been deposited where the gradient shows a sharp decline, as evident from the presence of four A horizons reaching to a depth of 150 cm in Pedon 5 (Table 2). Thus, whereas Pedons 2, 3, and 5 are classified as Andisols, the removal of andic soil properties along with the erosion of topsoil material results in the classification of Pedon 4 as an Inceptisol.
As a result of drier conditions, halloysite becomes increasingly dominant in the colloidal fraction of pedons below 3200 m asl, whereas allophane and Alhumus complexes only occur in the upper profile of pedons between 3200 and 2700 m asl and are absent below 2700 m asl. Larger amounts and higher crystallinity of halloysite in the C1 than in the underlying C2 horizon of Pedon 4 (Fig. 2 and 3) suggest pedogenic origin with enhanced weathering closer to the soil surface. The coexistence of allophane and halloysite in recent soils at intermediate elevation marks a transition from the allophane-dominated soils at high elevation to the halloysite-dominated soils at low elevation. Leaching during the rainy season appears to lower soil solution Si activity sufficiently in the upper profile and thus trigger the formation of allophane in the upper soil horizons of this transition zone, whereas desiccation during the dry season may promote the formation of halloysite. Similar differential formation of amorphous and crystalline weathering products with fluctuating leaching and desiccation periods has been proposed by Takahashi et al. (1993) for volcanic ash soils in the xeric moisture regime of northern California.
Elevated topsoil clay contents in pedons above 2700 m asl may be the result of a more aggressive weathering environment involving greater leaching and diurnal freezethaw cycles; however, part of the clay fraction may arise from minor additions of fine-textured tephra from surrounding volcanoes, which may have been deposited in the higher-lying western part of the study area. The lower soil pH (H2O) values at higher elevations are believed to arise from greater proton inputs with increased precipitation, greater leaching of basic cations, and greater activity of organic acids as a result of slowed organic matter decomposition.
Pedogenesis of Paleosols
Paleosols buried by the recent volcanic deposits are frequently encountered in the study area. Some mixing of new deposits with the old surface may have occurred upon deposition of recent tephra. This seems to be noticeable in Pedons 1 through 4, where the upper Ab horizons have significantly lower organic C contents than the Ab horizons underneath (Table 2). The pedogenesis of paleosols has been taking place over a longer time and under climatic conditions that may have deviated from those of the present day.
It has been shown for volcanic ash soils that humus evolves over time from forms with low complexing ability to forms with high complexing ability for Al (Wada, 1980). This appears to be the case in the paleosols of Pedons 10 and 11, which are highly indurated and presumably represent the oldest soils encountered in the study area. Higher clay contents and smaller amounts of primary minerals as compared with the recent soils reflect the prolonged exposure of paleosols to the processes of weathering. Nevertheless, the composition of their colloidal fraction shows virtually the same altitudinal sequence observed in the recent soils, with allophane and Alhumus complexes dominating at higher elevations and halloysite dominating at lower elevations. However, the contents of these constituents are higher in paleosols than in recent soils (Table 3, Fig. 2).
The highest allophane contents among the studied soils were found in paleosols above 3200 m asl (Table 3). This may reflect longer soil development as well as differences in parent material compared with the overlying recent soils. The paleosols of Pedons 1 and 2 are believed to have formed after the last glaciation, which reached as low as 3400 to 3600 m asl (Schubert and Clapperton, 1990), approximately 10 000 to 12 000 yr ago. The paleosols of Pedons 3 and 4 have formed on tephra deposits that are believed to be associated with earlier eruptions from the volcanic complex of Cotacachi with an age of more than 40 000 yr (Hall and Mothes, 1994). In a road cut near Pedon 1, the buried A horizons were found to directly overlie what appear to be colluvial deposits of unweathered volcanic rocks. The abrupt boundary between this colluvium and the deepest Ab horizon and the absence of weathered rock fragments in the Ab horizon point to a paleosol parent material different from the colluvium, possibly glacial outwash deposited on top of the colluvium. In this case, the parent material could have been preweathered and already contained allophane at the beginning of postglacial pedogenesis in the early Holocene, which would explain the relatively high allophane contents in the 2Ab3 horizon of Pedon 1 (Table 3).
Wada (1980) reported interaction of soil organic matter with allophane in buried A horizons to result in the formation of stable silt- and sand-sized aggregates that are resistant to dispersion. The presence of such aggregates in the Ab horizons of high-elevation pedons is suggested by pronounced differences between measured and estimated clay contents (Table 2). In these horizons, complexation with humic substances may have stabilized and protected allophane against dissolution and thus fostered its accumulation over time. A significant fraction of the humus complexing sites may be associated with Al from allophanic structures, possibly through ligand exchange of carboxyl groups to aluminol surface groups (Harsh, 2000).
Small amounts of fairly crystalline halloysite were found in the 2C3 horizon of Pedon 3 (Fig. 2 and 4), which also contains significant amounts of allophane (Table 3). The presence of halloysite in the paleosol of this pedon may be explained by increased Si inputs due to leaching from the recent depositional overburden. In that case, the conditions favoring halloysite formation would have been established with the deposition of recent tephra about 3000 yr BP. However, the halloysite found in the paleosol of Pedon 3 is clearly more crystalline than that found in the recent tephra of Pedon 4 (Fig. 3 and 4). This suggests that the former has formed over a longer time, possibly under different climatic conditions. In fact, pollen analyses in lacustrine sediments near the study area reveal evidence for a drier climate in the late-glacial period (Colinvaux et al., 1988), which could have resulted in the preferential formation of halloysite in Pedon 3. As the climate became moister at the beginning of the Holocene (Colinvaux et al., 1988), increased leaching may have lowered soil solution Si activities thus favoring the dissolution of halloysite and the precipitation of allophane.
| SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This altitudinal weathering sequence was observed in the 3000-yr-old recent soils and in paleosols considered older than 40 000 yr, which shows that different time of soil development has not caused marked differences in the formation and transformation of colloidal weathering products.
Climate is considered the overriding factor responsible for the observed altitudinal differences in soil development. Differences in rainfall and evapotranspiration resulting in different leaching regimes are believed to have caused the differential formation of allophane or halloysite and thus the differential development of andic soil properties. Temperature has further affected organic matter decomposition causing increased accumulation with elevation and thus resulting in the altitude-dependent formation of different epipedons.
There is some evidence that halloysite formed at higher elevations under the drier climatic conditions of the late-glacial. Thus, while the observed trends suggest altitudinal zonation with respect to soil formation, the boundaries between the zones may shift according to climatic changes over time. Moreover, the effects of topography on soil development may be superimposed on the general altitudinal trends, as observed on the steep-sloping parts of the study area, where andic soil properties have been removed from backslope positions along with the erosion of topsoil material.
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
Received for publication September 30, 2002.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
C. Rasmussen, N. Matsuyama, R. A. Dahlgren, R. J. Southard, and N. Brauer Soil Genesis and Mineral Transformation Across an Environmental Gradient on Andesitic Lahar Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J., January 1, 2007; 71(1): 225 - 237. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. Zanelli, M. Egli, A. Mirabella, M. Abdelmoula, M. Plotze, and M. Notzli 'BLACK' SOILS IN THE SOUTHERN ALPS: CLAY MINERAL FORMATION AND TRANSFORMATION, X-RAY AMORPHOUS Al PHASES AND Fe FORMS Clays and Clay Minerals, December 1, 2006; 54(6): 703 - 720. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| The SCI Journals | Agronomy Journal | Crop Science | |||
| Journal of Natural Resources and Life Sciences Education |
Vadose Zone Journal | ||||
| Journal of Plant Registrations | Journal of Environmental Quality |
The Plant Genome | |||