SSSAJ Grow Your Career with SSSA
HOME HELP FEEDBACK SUBSCRIPTIONS ARCHIVE SEARCH TABLE OF CONTENTS
 QUICK SEARCH:   [advanced]


     


This Article
Right arrow Abstract Freely available
Right arrow Figures Only
Right arrow Full Text (PDF) Free
Right arrow Alert me when this article is cited
Right arrow Alert me if a correction is posted
Services
Right arrow Similar articles in this journal
Right arrow Similar articles in ISI Web of Science
Right arrow Alert me to new issues of the journal
Right arrow Download to citation manager
Right arrow reprints & permissions
Citing Articles
Right arrow Citing Articles via HighWire
Right arrow Citing Articles via ISI Web of Science (5)
Right arrow Citing Articles via Google Scholar
Google Scholar
Right arrow Articles by Drury, C. F.
Right arrow Articles by Vyn, T. J.
Right arrow Search for Related Content
PubMed
Right arrow Articles by Drury, C. F.
Right arrow Articles by Vyn, T. J.
Agricola
Right arrow Articles by Drury, C. F.
Right arrow Articles by Vyn, T. J.
Related Collections
Right arrow Crop Growth and Development
Right arrow Clover
Right arrow Tillage
Soil Science Society of America Journal 67:867-877 (2003)
© 2003 Soil Science Society of America

DIVISION S-6—SOIL & WATER MANAGEMENT & CONSERVATION

Impacts of Zone Tillage and Red Clover on Corn Performance and Soil Physical Quality

C. F. Drury*,a, C. S. Tana, W. D. Reynoldsa, T. W. Welackya, S. E. Weavera, A. S. Hamilla and T. J. Vynb

a Greenhouse & Processing Crops Research Centre, Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada, Harrow, ON, Canada N0R 1G0
b Dep. of Agronomy, Purdue Univ., West Lafayette, IN 47907-1150

* Corresponding author (druryc{at}agr.gc.ca)


    ABSTRACT
 TOP
 ABSTRACT
 INTRODUCTION
 MATERIALS AND METHODS
 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
 CONCLUSIONS
 REFERENCES
 
Despite extensive research, reduced corn (Zea mays L.) performance is still encountered using conservation tillage on fine-textured soils in cool humid temperate climates. These problems are intensified when corn is planted into residue from a previous crop such as winter wheat (Triticum aestivum L.). The objective of this 4-yr study was to determine the influence of fall zone tillage (ZT), no tillage (NT), and conventional moldboard plow tillage (CT) (fall plowing) on corn performance and soil physical quality under a winter wheat–corn–soybean (Glycine max L. Merr.) rotation with and without red clover (Trifolium pratense L.) (RC) underseeded in the wheat phase of the rotation. A randomized complete block design (3 x 2 factorial, 4 replicates) was established on three adjacent fields in the fall of 1996 on a Brookston clay loam soil (fine loamy, mixed, mesic, Typic Argiaquoll) at Woodslee, ON Canada, and measurements were collected during 1997 to 2000. Over both wet and dry growing seasons from 1998-2000, zone tillage following underseeded RC produced average corn grain yields (7.23 Mg ha-1) that were within 1% of those obtained using conventional tillage (7.33 Mg ha-1), and 36% higher than those obtained using no tillage and RC (5.33 Mg ha-1). Zone tillage also improved soil quality as evidenced by generally lower soil strength than no tillage, and near-surface soil physical quality parameters that were equivalent to, or more favorable than, those of the other treatments. It was concluded that corn production using zone tillage and RC underseeding is a viable option in Brookston clay loam soil, as it retains much of the soil quality benefit of conventional tillage but still achieves most of the yield benefit of conventional moldboard plow tillage.

Abbreviations: CHU, corn heat unit • CT, conventional moldboard plow tillage • FC, field capacity • NT, no tillage • PR, penetration resistance • PWP, permanent wilting point • RC, red clover • WAS, wet aggregate stability • ZT, zone tillage


    INTRODUCTION
 TOP
 ABSTRACT
 INTRODUCTION
 MATERIALS AND METHODS
 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
 CONCLUSIONS
 REFERENCES
 
CONSERVATION-TILLAGE SYSTEMS, such as no-till, have been demonstrated to have several advantages over conventional moldboard plow systems, including reduced soil erosion and surface runoff, slower loss of soil organic matter, and lower production costs. However, there are many reports of reduced corn emergence and yields under no-till relative to conventional till on fine-textured soils in humid and cool temperate climates. This appears to be primarily a result of spring soil conditions that are cooler (Graven and Carter, 1991; Fortin and Pierce, 1990; Fortin and Pierce, 1991) and wetter (Fortin, 1993) relative to conventional tillage, plus other factors such as increased soil bulk density and strength (e.g., Hill, 1990; Pierce et al., 1992), decreased soil air-filled porosity and saturated hydraulic conductivity (e.g., Pierce et al., 1992), and desiccation of seeds or seedlings through reopening of the planting slot produced by the no-till planter (Drury et al., 1999).

Zone tillage has been proposed as a possible alternative tillage system that may combine the soil quality benefits of conservation tillage with the yield benefits of conventional moldboard plow tillage (e.g., Pierce et al., 1992) for cool humid climatic zones. Here, a narrow zone 10 to 20 cm wide by 10 to 30 cm deep is conventionally tilled in the crop row while the rest of the soil surface is left in an untouched no-till state. This supposedly encourages the more favorable soil temperature, moisture, aeration, density, and strength conditions associated with conventional tillage in the narrow seedbed zones, while retaining the increased erosion resistance, organic matter protection and reduced energy inputs of no tillage between the zones. Although there is much interest in the zone-till system, it has not yet been tested extensively in cool humid temperate climates, nor on the agriculturally important clay and clay loam soils of southern Ontario. In nearby Michigan, ZT on sandy loam soils did indeed improve potato (Solanum tuberosum L.) yields and soil physical conditions relative to conventional tillage in most years of a 4-yr study (Pierce and Burpee, 1995); however, corn yields were not increased by zone tillage in a similar 3-yr study, despite substantially reduced soil strength (penetration resistance) within the 0- to 30-cm depth range (Pierce et al., 1992).

Red clover underseeded in cereals can produce large quantities of plant biomass and it fixes N in the nodules, which can in turn provide the equivalent of 90 to 125 kg N ha-1 to the following crop (Bruulsema and Christie, 1987). In addition, RC can be effective in cool-temperate climates for increasing microbial biomass, improving the structure of fine-textured soils (Drury et al., 1991), and for accelerating the decomposition of surface crop residues (Drury et al., 1999). It was consequently hypothesized that including RC underseeding in a crop rotation might further improve the potential yield and soil quality benefits of zone tillage on fine-textured soils.

The objective of this study was to determine, for a clay loam soil in southern Ontario, if zone tillage and RC underseeding could achieve corn yields comparable with conventional moldboard plow tillage, but still retain most of the soil quality, environmental, and reduced energy inputs of no tillage. To accomplish this, conventional moldboard plow tillage, no tillage, and zone-tillage systems were applied to a winter wheat–corn–soybean rotation, with and without RC underseeded in the winter wheat. Evaluations were made on the basis of corn emergence, corn yield, and near-surface soil physical quality.


    MATERIALS AND METHODS
 TOP
 ABSTRACT
 INTRODUCTION
 MATERIALS AND METHODS
 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
 CONCLUSIONS
 REFERENCES
 
Experimental Design and Agronomic Operations
Three adjacent fields were established in the fall of 1996 on a Brookston clay loam soil at Woodslee, ON (42° 13' N lat., 82° 44' W long.), so that each crop in the winter wheat–corn–soybean rotation would be present each year during the 1997-2000 study period. In the plow layer (top 15 cm), the soil has an average texture of 28% sand, 35% silt, and 37% clay, and an average organic C content of 20 g kg-1 (under long-term conventional tillage). The climate is humid, and cool-temperate, with a mean annual air temperature of 8.7°C, and an average annual precipitation of 827 mm. The treatments were a 3 by 2 factorial arrangement of tillage and RC underseeded in winter wheat with four replicates. The treatments included CT, ZT, and NT, each with or without red clover (± RC) underseeded in the winter wheat phase of the rotation. The treatment plots were 20 m long by 9 m wide. Conventional tillage consisted of moldboard plowing in the fall to a 15-cm depth, with secondary disking and harrowing in the following spring just before planting (May-June). Zone tillage was performed in the fall using a Trans Till (Row Tech Inc. Snover, MI) single shank unit with a wavy coulter on either side of the shank to produce tilled strips that were 21 cm wide, 15 cm deep, and spaced 75 cm apart. Corn was planted directly into the tilled strips in the following spring without further tillage. All phases of the rotation receiving conventional tillage are plowed in the fall every year, the treatments receiving no-till are never plowed and those receiving zone tillage are tilled in the fall before corn and were not tilled before the soybean and winter wheat phases of the rotation.

No tillage produced no disturbance of the soil except for that caused by the no-till planter. Before the establishment of this study, the conventional-till and no-till plots had been in place under a winter wheat–corn–soybean rotation since 1993. The zone-till treatment was introduced into a subset of the no-till plots in the fall of 1996. The data reported here apply only to the corn phase of the rotation from 1997-2000.

Corn was planted (76 100 seeds ha-1) in 75-cm rows for all three tillage treatments using a John Deere 6-row no-till Max Emerge planter (Deere and Company, Moline, IL) equipped with 45.72-cm (18-inch) ripple and bubble coulters to open and close the planting slot, plus residue managers to improve the seed bed. The planter was adjusted among tillage treatments to ensure that the same 4-cm planting depth was achieved for each tillage treatment. Planting was delayed in 1997 and 2000 because of wet soil conditions resulting from high spring rainfall (Table 1). The delay was long enough in 1997 to require an early-maturing 2950 corn heat unit (CHU) variety (Pioneer 3752), whereas in 1998, 1999, and 2000 a normal 3250 CHU variety (NK Max 21) was used. To encourage early plant growth, liquid fertilizer (55 L ha-1) was applied with the seed to provide 5.6 kg N ha-1, 9.8 kg P ha-1, and 9.3 kg K ha-1. Nitrogen (22 kg N ha-1), P (38 kg P ha-1), and K (37 kg K ha-1) were also applied at planting in a band 5 cm beside and 5 cm below the seed. When the corn had four visible collors (6-leaf stage), N (28% UAN) was injected (148 kg N ha-1) in a band 15 cm away from the row at a 10-cm depth.


View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Table 1. Growing season (April-August) precipitation at Woodslee, ON.

 
All plots were sprayed with 1.8 kg ai ha-1 glyphosate [N-(phosphonomethyl) glycine] plus 1.0 kg ai ha-1 2,4-D [(2,4-dichlorophenoxy) acetic acid] in the fall to kill perennial weeds, RC, and volunteer wheat. At the time of corn planting, all plots were sprayed with 1.68 kg ai ha-1 pendimethalin [N-(1-ethylpropyl)-3,4-dimethyl-2,6-dinitro benzene-amine] plus 1.0 kg ai ha-1 atrazine (2-chloro-4-ethylamino-6-isopropylamino-s-triazine) pre-emergence, to control newly emerging weeds.

Measurements
Corn Emergence and Yield
Corn emergence was measured between four to twelve times per week over 2 to 3 wk until all of the viable plants emerged. Four 2-m row lengths per plot were marked with flags after planting to measure both the emergence rate and final crop stand. Plants were counted every 1 to 2 d within the marked areas until emergence was complete. Two subsamples were harvested from each plot with three rows of corn (20 m long) in each subsample on 6 Nov. 1997, 16 Nov. 1998, 29 Oct. 1999, and 15 Nov. 2000 with a Gleaner combine (Allis Chamers, Millwaukee, WI). Total corn grain yields and grain moisture content were measured and yields were normalized to 150 g kg-1 grain moisture content.

Surface Residue
Surface residue weights were measured 4 to 5 times per growing season from 1997-2000. The residue was collected from the soil surface within 20 by 76 cm metal rectangles placed perpendicular to the corn rows with two measurements made in every plot (n = 8). The residue was oven-dried at 80°C and any soil adhering to the residue was removed before a dry residue mass was determined. The sampling areas were weed-free and no living plant material was included in the residue sample.

Soil Moisture and Temperature
Volumetric soil water content measurements were made in situ in the corn row midway between plants three times per week at the 0- to 5- and 0- to 30-cm depths in four replicates of each treatment using time domain reflectometry (Topp et al., 1980; Topp, 1993). The 0- to 5-cm depth measurements were made only during germination and early growth (from planting to about the 6-leaf stage), while the 0- to 30-cm depth measurements were made for the entire growing season (from planting to the end of August). Soil temperature was measured during germination and early growth using four thermocouples inserted horizontally into the undisturbed soil profile at 5- and 10-cm depths in two replicates of each treatment. The temperature measurements were made continuously and integrated hourly using a CR-10 micrologger.

Soil Physical Quality Parameters
Estimates of in-row soil strength (cone penetration resistance) were made midway between corn plants in 1998-2000 approximately 3 wk after corn planting, using a RIMIK CP-20 cone penetrometer (Agridry Rimik, Toowoomba, Queensland, Australia) (cone basal area = 1.2 cm2, cone angle = 30°, 0–45 cm depth range, three penetrations per plot, n = 12). During the summers of 1998-2000, intact soil cores (7.6-cm diam. by 7.6-cm long) and grab samples were collected at the 5.0- to 12.6-cm depth from the corn row midway between plants (n = 8, two cores and two grab samples per plot). The 5.0- to 12.6-cm depth range was selected to reduce the near-surface artifact effects of soil cracking, but still include the near-surface effects of the tillage and red clover treatments. The cores and grab samples were used to determine dry bulk density (Culley, 1993), air-filled porosity (porosity minus volumetric water content at -100 cm pressure head), plant-available water capacity (volumetric water content at -100 cm pressure head minus volumetric water content at -15 bar pressure head, Topp et al., 1993), and saturated hydraulic conductivity (Reynolds, 1993). Soil grab samples were collected from each treatment from 1997 to 2000 at a depth of 0- to 5-cm to determine near-surface treatment effects on wet aggregate stability (Kemper and Rosenau, 1986).

Statistical Analyses
A 3 by 2 factorial randomized complete block design was used with four replicates. Treatment and interaction effects were tested for statistical significance using analysis of variance (SAS Institute, 2001). When interactions between tillage and red clover treatment were not significant, we also evaluated main effect means using a least-significant-difference test (LSD) at P = 0.05.


    RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
 TOP
 ABSTRACT
 INTRODUCTION
 MATERIALS AND METHODS
 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
 CONCLUSIONS
 REFERENCES
 
Precipitation and Corn Performance
Year 1997
The May and June rainfall in 1997 were 48 and 8%, respectively, above the corresponding 30-yr averages (Table 1), which delayed corn planting until June 10. The rainfall in July, on the other hand, was 47% below the 30-yr average, while that in August was virtually the same as the 30-yr average (Table 1).

Corn emergence in 1997 was very rapid under the conventional tillage treatments, but much slower under zone-tillage and no-tillage treatments (Fig. 1) . By Day 5, 26 to 32% of the corn plants had emerged in the conventional-tillage treatments but no plants had emerged on either the zone-tillage or no-tillage treatments. Fifty percent corn emergence was reached in the conventional-tillage treatments by Day 6, which was significantly greater than the emergence rates for both the zone-tillage and no-tillage treatments. Between 9 to 10 d were required for 50% emergence in zone-tillage and no-tillage treatments. Red clover had no significant effect on emergence rates, except for zone tillage between approximately Day 7 and Day 10, where corn emerged faster under ZT + RC relative to ZT. Final plant stands were not significantly different between tillage or RC treatments with emergence rates of 95% for the conventional-tillage treatments, 91% for the zone-tillage treatments, and 87% for the no-tillage treatments.



View larger version (31K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Fig. 1. Corn emergence in 1997, 1998, 1999, and 2000 for the conventional tillage (CT), zone tillage (ZT), and no-tillage (NT) treatments with and without underseeded red clover (RC). The vertical bars indicate standard error (n = 8).

 
Despite the late planting date and slow emergence (for the zone-tillage and no-tillage treatments), corn grain yields were high for all treatments in 1997, ranging from 9.1 to 9.8 Mg ha-1 (Table 2). There were no significant tillage, RC, or tillage x RC interaction effects with respect to corn grain yields (Table 2).


View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Table 2. Corn grain yields on a Brookston clay loam soil under conventional tillage (CT), zone tillage (ZT), and no-tillage (NT) with and without red clover (RC) underseeded into the winter wheat phase of a wheat–corn–soybean rotation.

 
Year 1998
The April rainfall was 15% greater than the 30 yr average, however rainfall in May, June, and July was 55, 52, and 28%, respectively below the 30-yr averages for these months (Table 1). Corn in all treatments was consequently stressed at the end of July; however 84 mm of rain fell between August 1st and 10th with a total of 128 mm for August, which was 56% greater than the 30-yr average rainfall.

The 1998 corn emergence rates were greatest under the conventional-tillage treatments, much slower under the no-tillage treatments, and intermediate under the zone-tillage treatments (Fig. 1). For example, after 8 d, the conventional-tillage treatments had a 56% emergence rate, which was significantly greater than the zone-tillage treatments (19%), which in turn was significantly greater than the no-tillage treatments (3%). There were no significant effects of RC on corn emergence at 8 d. Final plant stands were statistically similar for the conventional-tillage and zone-tillage treatments (80–86%), whereas they were both significantly greater than the no-tillage treatments (52%). Corn emergence rates were affected by RC in the zone-tillage treatments only, where corn emergence was faster under ZT than under ZT + RC especially between the 9th and 12th day after planting.

In 1998, there were significant tillage and RC effects on corn grain yields (Table 2). The corn grain yields for the CT + RC, CT, and ZT + RC treatments were similar but significantly greater than the yields for ZT, NT + RC, and NT (P = 0.1). The no tillage without RC underseeding (NT) and NT + RC treatments had by far the lowest corn grain yields (2.64 and 3.61 Mg ha-1, respectively) which were 61 to 70% lower than the two corresponding conventional-tillage treatments (8.92 and 9.26 Mg ha-1). Red clover underseeding increased yields by an average of 21% across the three tillages (4% for CT, 37% for NT, and 40% for ZT). The 1998 corn grain yields were 5 to 60% lower than those in 1997, probably because of the 28 to 55% lower rainfall in May-July relative to the corresponding 30-yr averages (Table 1). The particularly low yields for the two no-tillage treatments were probably caused at least partially by severe seed and seedling desiccation after pronounced reopening of the planting slots in those treatments.

Year 1999
The precipitation in 1999 was above the 30-yr average for April, but well below the 30-yr averages in May, June, July, and August (Table 1). In particular, the May 1 through August 31 rainfall (172.3 mm) was only about half the 30-yr average (340.8 mm). The corn plants consequently had a high emergence rate (Fig. 1) and initial growth, but then became severely drought stressed (especially during the grain filling period) which resulted in low grain yields for all treatments (Table 2).

The 1999 corn emergence rates were rapid and very similar among all six treatments (Fig. 1). Final plant stands were also high and no significant difference was found among treatments, with emergence being 88 to 91% for the two conventional-tillage treatments, 94 to 95% for the two no-tillage treatments, and 91 to 93% for the two zone-tillage treatments. We believe this occurred because 26.5 mm of rain fell during the 3 d after planting (21–23 May 1999), and because the planter slot did not reopen in the two no-tillage treatments, as it had in 1997 and 1998.

Corn grain yields in 1999 were similar for the conventional-tillage and zone-tillage treatments (4.4–4.7 Mg ha-1), but lower for the no-tillage treatments (3.7 Mg ha-1), which resulted in a significant tillage effect (Table 2). Red clover underseeded in the previous winter wheat crop did not improve corn grain yields in 1999, and no significant interactions between RC and tillage occurred. Averaged over the RC treatments, conventional tillage and zone tillage produced corn grain yields that were greater than no tillage by 21 and 25%, respectively.

Year 2000
The 2000 growing season was very wet, exceeding the monthly and cumulative 30-yr averages by substantial margins (Table 1). As a result, corn planting was delayed by wet soil conditions until June 2. Corn emergence rates were rapid, although slower for the two no-tillage treatments relative to the other treatments (Fig. 1). For example, after 8 d, conventional-tillage treatments had 58% emergence, which was significantly greater than the zone-tillage treatments (44%), and the zone-tillage treatments had significantly greater emergence than no-tillage treatments (11%). Red clover did not affect emergence in 2000. Final plant stands were nonetheless uniformly high for all treatments (>=90%), and no significant tillage or RC effects were evident.

Corn grain yields were substantial and fairly uniform in 2000, ranging from a low of 8.25 Mg ha-1 for ZT to a high of 9.02 Mg ha-1 for CT + RC, with no significant tillage, RC or tillage by RC interaction effects (Table 2).

Comparison of Average Corn Yields
The treatments were compared using corn grain yields averaged over 1998, 1999, and 2000 (Table 2). The 1997 yields were excluded from the comparison because the NT treatment was missing for that year. There was a highly significant tillage effect (P <= 0.001) and a significant RC effect (P <= 0.05) and the interaction between tillage and RC treatment was not significant (Table 2). Averaged over the RC treatments, the 3-yr average of the corn grain yields from 1998-2000 were significantly greater (P <= 0.001) for the conventional-tillage treatments (7.44 Mg ha-1), than the zone-tillage treatments (6.71 Mg ha-1), which was in turn significantly greater than the corn grain yields for the no-tillage treatments (5.17 Mg ha-1). Averaged over tillage treatments, including RC in the rotation resulted in significantly (P = 0.05) greater corn grain yields (6.70 Mg ha-1) than treatments without RC (6.18 Mg ha-1). Although the conventional-tillage treatments produced the greatest average yields, the ZT + RC yield was only 4% lower than CT + RC and only 1% lower than CT. The average NT + RC yield, on the other hand, was 29% lower than CT + RC and 27% lower than CT. Red clover resulted in an average yield increase of 9% across all tillages; and was especially effective for zone tillage, producing an average yield increase of 17% relative to no RC. Consequently, ZT + RC appears capable, on average, of producing corn yields, which are competitive with those from CT on a Brookston clay loam soil under a winter wheat–corn–soybean rotation.

Surface Crop Residue
As expected, crop residue on the soil surface varied substantially with tillage treatment, time of year and across years (Fig. 2) . Residue cover over the two conventional tillage treatments varied from highs of 0.1 to 1.8 Mg ha-1 in the spring to lows of <0.2 Mg ha-1 in the fall. Surface residue over the four conservational-tillage treatments, on the other hand, ranged from highs of 2.6 to 7.4 Mg ha-1 in the spring, to lows of 0.9 to 3.1 Mg ha-1 in the fall. Note that 1999 was an exception in that residue covers did not decline appreciably over the growing season for any of the treatments. This was attributed to the very dry 1999 growing season (Table 1), which undoubtedly limited biological decomposition on the soil surface. In October 1997, 1998, and 2000, ZT + RC had, respectively, 33, 49, and 31% less residue cover than ZT; and in 1998 and 2000, NT + RC had 35% less residue cover than NT (Fig. 2). Red clover has a low C/N ratio as a result of symbiotic N fixation and it also has a considerable amount of soluble C, which has been found to stimulate biological activity (McKenney et al., 1993). Hence, it is readily decomposed by soil microorganisms, which leads to an increase in soil ammonium through mineralization. In contrast wheat straw residue has a high C/N ratio and its decomposition is limited by available N. Hence the additional supply of inorganic N from RC decomposition probably contributed to the decomposition of wheat straw, which was underseeded to RC. The accelerated decomposition of wheat residues by including RC in the rotation, was observed previously by Drury et al. (1999).



View larger version (29K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Fig. 2. Surface residue cover in 1997, 1998, 1999, and 2000 for the conventional tillage (CT), zone tillage (ZT), and no-tillage (NT) treatments with and without underseeded red clover (RC). The vertical bars indicate standard error (n = 8).

 
Soil Temperature and Water Content
During the emergence and early growth periods of 1997-1999, the two conventional-tillage treatments had slightly greater average soil temperatures at the 5- and 10-cm depths than the other treatments (Table 3). There was also a tendency during those years (notwithstanding a few exceptions) for the two no-tillage treatments to have the lowest temperatures, and for the two zone-tillage treatments to have intermediate temperatures relative to the conventional-tillage treatments. There was little difference among any of the average soil temperatures in 2000, although CT clearly had the greatest soil temperature at the 10-cm depth, while both CT and NT had the greatest temperatures at the 5-cm depth. It was also noted that RC underseeding had no apparent effect on average soil temperature, except in 2000 where RC underseeding tended to produce slightly lower average temperatures at the 5-cm depth (especially for NT + RC). Given that the average soil temperatures were all above 20°C, it is unlikely that temperature contributed in any major way to the highly variable corn emergence patterns and plant stands observed among treatments (in 1997 and 1998) and among years (Fig. 1).


View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Table 3. Average soil temperature and volumetric water content (m3 m-3) in a Brookston clay loam soil under conventional tillage (CT), zone tillage (ZT), and no-tillage (NT) with and without red clover (RC) underseeded into the winter wheat phase of a wheat–corn–soybean rotation. Measurements were taken in the corn phase.

 
Average soil water content at the 0- to 5-cm depth was slightly lower under CT and CT + RC in most years, but no trends or patterns in water content were evident among the other treatments (Table 3). At the 0- to 30-cm depth, on the other hand, there was a tendency (albeit not entirely consistent) for average soil water content to change with tillage, that is, the two conventional-tillage treatments yielded the lowest values, the two zone-tillage treatments generally yielded intermediate values, and the two no-tillage treatments usually yielded the highest values. The average soil water contents at the 0- to 5-cm depth were very low in 1998 and 1999 for all treatments, which is consistent with the very low May and June rainfall during those years (Table 1). By the same token, the relatively high average water contents for all treatments at the 0- to 5-cm depth in 2000 reflect the high May and June rainfall for that year (Table 1). As expected, the average water contents at the 0- to 30-cm depth were generally much greater than at the 0- to 5-cm depth, and the year-to-year variation in water content followed the same general pattern as that of the 0- to 5-cm depth. It was noted that RC underseeding had a significant effect on average soil water content over the depth ranges investigated in 1999. In all the tillage treatments, RC underseeding had greater soil water content relative to no RC.

Many field crops tend to perform best when average root-zone water contents fall within a range defined at the wet end by the soil's field capacity (FC) water content and at the dry end by the soil's permanent-wilting point (PWP) water content (Kramer, 1969). The depth-averaged FC and PWP water contents for the soil were 0.36 and 0.25 m3 m-3, respectively, over the 0- to 5-cm depth, and 0.32 and 0.20 m3 m-3, respectively, over the 0- to 30-cm depth. Average water contents at 0 to 5 cm and 0 to 30 cm were within the FC and PWP limits in 1997 and 2000 (Table 3), and this is consistent with the moderate to high corn yields for those years (Table 2). In 1998 and 1999, however, the average soil water contents were at or below the PWP limits (Table 3), which is again consistent with the moderate to very low corn yields for those years (Table 2).

Soil Physical Quality
Cone Penetration Resistance
The variability and overall shapes of the cone penetration resistance profiles changed substantially between 1998, 1999, and 2000 (Fig. 3) . This most likely occurred because cone penetrometer measurements can be very sensitive to small changes in soil bulk density, water content, texture, organic C content, and structure (e.g., Bengough et al., 2001). Among-year variability may also have been exacerbated by the fact that each year's measurements corresponded to a different (although adjacent) field. It is unlikely, however, that soil water content contributed substantially to among-treatment variability within each year (or field) because water content differences were small at the time of the penetrometer measurements, and water content did not correlate with penetration resistance (PR) (data not shown).



View larger version (34K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Fig. 3. Mean penetration resistance in 1998, 1999, and 2000 for the conventional tillage (CT), zone tillage (ZT) and no-tillage (NT) treatments with and without underseeded red clover (RC). The horizontal bars indicate LSD value at P = 0.05 (n = 12).

 
In 1998, a tillage effect on cone PR was clearly evident over about the 5- to 30-cm depth, with the two no-tillage treatments yielding the greatest PR values followed by the two zone-tillage treatments and then the two conventional-tillage treatments (Fig. 3). A RC effect was evident only for no-tillage, with NT + RC yielding greater PR values over the 5- to 30-cm depth than NT. Bengough and Mullins (1991) suggested that the growth rate of corn seedling roots in sandy loam soils decrease linearly with increasing PR, resulting in a 50% reduction at PR approximately 2000 kPa. Comparable results were reported in Bennie (1996), where it is showed that 70 d growth in lysimeters at PR = 2000 kPa produces about a 66% reduction in corn root length relative to uncompacted controls (PR ~ 500 kPa). Our corn grain yield patterns are consistent with the above PR results in that greater average PR in the 0- to 30-cm depth range corresponds with lower yields (Table 2).

In 1999, both tillage and RC effects were evident, with tillage having a far greater effect than RC (Fig. 3). Over approximately the 5- to 25-cm depth, the two no-tillage treatments produced the greatest PR values, with NT + RC producing slightly greater values than NT. From about 5 to 13 cm, the two conventional-tillage treatments produced greater PR values than the two zone-tillage treatments, while from about 20 to 30 cm the two zone-tillage treatments produced greater values than the two conventional-tillage treatments. It is also interesting to note that the small effects of RC on PR were reversed for conventional tillage relative to the other tillages within the 5- to 13-cm depth range. All six treatments reached or exceeded the PR = 2000 kPa value where root growth may be reduced by >=50% because of excessive soil strength (Bennie, 1996; Bengough and Mullins, 1991). This was likely because of the very dry soil conditions both throughout the growing season (Table 3) and at the time of the penetrometer measurements (data not shown). Note that the generally high average PR values correspond to the substantially lower 1999 corn grain yields for all treatments (Table 2). The PR profiles further indicate that the average soil mechanical resistance to crop root growth in the top 20 cm of soil was lowest under the two zone-tillage treatments, greatest under the two no-tillage treatments, and intermediate under the two conventional-tillage treatments. As in the previous year, these average PR values correlate with yield in that corn grain yield was the greatest under the zone-tillage treatments (albeit by a small margin), intermediate under the conventional tillage-treatments, and lowest under the no-tillage treatments (Table 2).

In 2000, the PR values were generally much lower than in 1998 and 1999 (Fig. 3). In addition, PR increased approximately linearly with increasing depth for all treatments, ranging from near zero close to the soil surface to 1600 to 2200 kPa at 45-cm depth, with no substantial differences among treatments. These results are most likely the result of the substantially greater precipitation (Table 1) and soil profile moisture contents (Table 3) throughout the 2000 growing season, relative to the 1998 and 1999 growing seasons. The slight but sudden divergence of the CT, CT + RC, and ZT profiles at about the 18-cm depth (Fig. 3) is currently unexplained, but may be related in some way to tillage operations in the previous fall (1999), which was much wetter than average. The lack of difference in average PR over the 0- to 20-cm depth is consistent with the lack of difference among corn grain yields (Table 2).

Comparing the 1998-2000 PR results, it appears that the two zone-tillage treatments produced the lowest overall soil strengths (i.e., lowest PR values) in a low rainfall year (1999), and intermediate overall strengths in a normal rainfall year (1998). Zone tillage was also found to decrease soil strength relative to conventional tillage in loam soils cropped to potatoes (Pierce and Burpee, 1995) and corn (Pierce et al., 1992). The two no-tillage treatments tended to produce the greatest overall soil strengths in the normal and low rainfall years (1998 and 1999, respectively), while the two conventional-tillage treatments produced the lowest overall soil strengths under normal rainfall (1998) and intermediate strengths under low rainfall (1999). Under high soil moisture conditions (2000), there were no substantial differences in soil strength among any of the treatments. Given the treatment differences in PR often decrease with increasing soil moisture (Bengough et al., 2001), this result suggests that high soil moisture can override tillage effects on soil strength in Brookston clay loam. For the 3-yr period, it appears that the two zone-tillage treatments had the most favorable overall soil strength profiles, as they maintained lower soil strengths than the other treatments during a dry year (1999), reasonable strengths during a normal rainfall year (1998), and similar strengths to the other treatments during a wet year (2000). The two no-tillage treatments, on the other hand, had the least favorable soil strength profiles, as they had the greatest strengths during a normal rainfall year (1998), and excessive strengths in a low rainfall year (1999). Red clover did not have important or consistent effects on soil strength under any of the tillage treatments in any of the 3 yr (Fig. 3). As mentioned above, corn grain yield tended to be negatively correlated with average soil strength, in that lower average PR corresponded with greater yield.

Additional Soil Parameters
Bulk density ranged from a high of 1.48 Mg m-3 (CT + RC, 2000) to a low of 1.28 Mg m-3 (ZT + RC, 2000) (Table 4). Significant tillage effects occurred in all 3 yr, and significant RC and tillage by clover interaction effects occurred in 2000. The optimal bulk density for root growth in fine-textured soils is on the order of 0.8 to 1.2 Mg m-3 (e.g., Olness et al., 1998, Reynolds et al., 2002), and root growth often stops completely in clayey soils at about 1.5 Mg m—3 (Veihmeyer and Hendrickson, 1948). Consequently, corn root growth was likely to have been somewhat impeded by high soil density for all six treatments, and especially under the CT + RC treatment in 2000. The ZT + RC treatment had either the lowest, or among the lowest, bulk density in each of the 3 yr, while the two no-tillage treatments often had the greatest bulk density. This pattern is generally consistent with the soil strength (Fig. 3) and corn yield (Table 2) patterns mentioned earlier.


View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Table 4. Bulk density, air-filled porosity, plant-available water capacity, and saturated hydraulic conductivity (Ksat) in a Brookston clay loam soil under conventional tillage (CT), zone tillage (ZT), and no-tillage (NT) with and without red clover (RC) underseeded into the winter wheat phase of a wheat–corn–soybean rotation. Measurements taken in the corn phase.

 
The air-filled porosities ranged from 0.14 to 0.20 m3m-3, with significant tillage and tillage by clover interaction effects in 1999 (Table 4). These values are, for the most part, near or above the suggested minimum of 0.15 m3m-3 for adequate near-surface aeration in the root-zone of clayey soils (Cockroft and Olsson, 1997). Significant or frequent near-surface aeration deficits are therefore unlikely in any of the six treatments, and no among-treatment patterns were evident.

Plant-available water capacity tended to be low, ranging from 0.089 m3m-3 (NT, 1998) to 0.142 m3m-3 (ZT + RC and NT, 2000), with no significant RC effects but significant tillage effects in 1998 and 1999 (Table 4). The low values occurred despite large FC water contents (0.31–0.34 m3m-3) because the PWP water contents were also large (0.18–0.23 m3m-3). It has been proposed that plant-available water capacities greater than 0.20 m3m-3 are required in fine-textured soils for optimal root growth, function, and minimum droughtiness (Cockroft and Olsson, 1997). Consequently, crops grown on all six treatments may be prone to periodic drought stress, even when the soil is still relatively moist (i.e., water contents as high as 0.23 m3m-3). No among-treatment patterns were evident.

Saturated hydraulic conductivity (Ksat) ranged from a low of 4.2 x 10-4 cm s-1 (CT + RC, 2000) to a high of 2.9 x 10-1 cm s-1 (ZT, 1999), with significant tillage effects in 1998 and 2000, but no significant RC effects (Table 4). No distinct patterns were evident, although the average Ksat in 1999 was greater than in 1998 or 2000, which corresponded with greater soil surface cracking observed in 1999 owing to very dry soil conditions (Table 3). Saturated hydraulic conductivity values in the range, 10-2 to 10-5 cm s-1, may provide an optimum between the competing needs for rapid sorption into the soil matrix of needed crop-available water, and rapid drainage of excess water that could cause water-logging and associated aeration deficits (Topp et al., 1997). All treatments exceeded this range, except for the two conventional-tillage treatments in 2000. Thus all treatments tended to be prone to near-surface droughtiness because infiltration and drainage in the near-surface soil may be too rapid to allow adequate sorption of crop-available water into the soil matrix. On the other hand, problems associated with near-surface water logging, erosion, and runoff are less likely.

Wet aggregate stability (WAS) was not consistently affected by tillage or RC (Fig. 4) . The WAS values were of similar magnitude ({approx}60%) among treatments and years, except for the two conventional-tillage treatments in 1997 and 2000 where WAS {approx} 30%. Generally speaking, RC increased the WAS slightly, however, this increase was not always significant, and exceptions occurred under conventional tillage in 1997 and 1998 and under no-tillage in 2000 where the RC treatment produced a slight decrease. The reasons for these exceptions are currently unknown. In three of the 4 yr the ZT + RC and NT + RC treatments had greater WAS than the two conventional-tillage treatments.



View larger version (43K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Fig. 4. Wet aggregate stability (WAS) at 0-5 cm depth in 1997, 1998, 1999, and 2000 for the conventional tillage (CT), zone tillage (ZT) and no-tillage (NT) treatments with and without underseeded red clover (RC). The vertical bars indicate standard error (n = 4).

 
Overall Treatment Effects on Soil Physical Quality
Generally speaking, the six treatments did not have large or consistent effects on the measured soil physical quality parameters during 1998, 1999, and 2000. However, there was a tendency (albeit not entirely consistent or always statistically significant) for ZT + RC to have near-surface parameter values that were equivalent to or somewhat more favorable than those of the other treatments (Table 4, Fig. 3 and 4). This implies as a consequence that the near surface soil physical quality under ZT + RC tended to be equivalent to, or slightly more favorable than, the soil physical quality under the other treatments.


    CONCLUSIONS
 TOP
 ABSTRACT
 INTRODUCTION
 MATERIALS AND METHODS
 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
 CONCLUSIONS
 REFERENCES
 
Tillage and RC underseeding were compared on a clay loam soil in southern Ontario in terms of corn performance and soil physical quality. The tillage treatments included fall zone tillage, no tillage, and conventional tillage using fall moldboard plowing. The cropping system was a winter wheat–corn–soybean rotation, with and without RC underseeding in the winter wheat phase. Fall zone tillage with RC underseeding produced the greatest, or among the greatest, corn grain yields in every year of the study, which included both wet and dry growing seasons. No tillage, on the other hand, often produced the lowest, or among the lowest, corn grain yields. Zone tillage with underseeded RC also tended to produce soil strength profiles and near-surface soil physical quality that were equivalent to, or slightly more favorable than, those of the other treatments. Fall zone tillage with RC underseeding thus appears viable for corn production in a wheat–corn–soybean rotation on fine-textured soils in southern Ontario, as it maintains much of the soil quality benefits of conservational tillage while retaining much of the yield benefit of conventional moldboard plow tillage.


    ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
 
We gratefully acknowledge the Ontario Corn Producers Association, the Canadian Adaptation Council (CanAdapt) and the Matching Investment Initiative (MII) program of Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada for providing financial support for this research. We also acknowledge Tom Oloya, Vic Bernyk, Wayne Calder, Karl Rinas, George Stasko, Joann Gignac, Don Pohlman, Mac Whaley, Scott Mannell, Mike Bissonnette, and Arpad Szabo for their valuable technical assistance.

Received for publication January 22, 2002.


    REFERENCES
 TOP
 ABSTRACT
 INTRODUCTION
 MATERIALS AND METHODS
 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
 CONCLUSIONS
 REFERENCES
 




This article has been cited by other articles:


Home page
Soil Sci.Home page
H. Blanco-Canqui and R. Lal
Regional Assessment of Soil Compaction and Structural Properties under No-tillage Farming
Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J., September 28, 2007; 71(6): 1770 - 1778.
[Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]


Home page
Agron. J.Home page
M. Perez-Bidegain, R. M. Cruse, and A. Ciha
Tillage System by Planting Date Interaction Effects on Corn and Soybean Yield
Agron. J., April 4, 2007; 99(3): 630 - 636.
[Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]


Home page
Agron. J.Home page
A. G. Kravchenko and K. D. Thelen
Effect of Winter Wheat Crop Residue on No-Till Corn Growth and Development
Agron. J., March 12, 2007; 99(2): 549 - 555.
[Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]


Home page
Soil Sci.Home page
C. F. Drury, W. D. Reynolds, C. S. Tan, T. W. Welacky, W. Calder, and N. B. McLaughlin
Emissions of Nitrous Oxide and Carbon Dioxide: Influence of Tillage Type and Nitrogen Placement Depth
Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J., February 27, 2006; 70(2): 570 - 581.
[Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]


Home page
Crop Sci.Home page
F. E. Miguez and G. A. Bollero
Review of Corn Yield Response under Winter Cover Cropping Systems Using Meta-Analytic Methods
Crop Sci., September 23, 2005; 45(6): 2318 - 2329.
[Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]


This Article
Right arrow Abstract Freely available
Right arrow Figures Only
Right arrow Full Text (PDF) Free
Right arrow Alert me when this article is cited
Right arrow Alert me if a correction is posted
Services
Right arrow Similar articles in this journal
Right arrow Similar articles in ISI Web of Science
Right arrow Alert me to new issues of the journal
Right arrow Download to citation manager
Right arrow reprints & permissions
Citing Articles
Right arrow Citing Articles via HighWire
Right arrow Citing Articles via ISI Web of Science (5)
Right arrow Citing Articles via Google Scholar
Google Scholar
Right arrow Articles by Drury, C. F.
Right arrow Articles by Vyn, T. J.
Right arrow Search for Related Content
PubMed
Right arrow Articles by Drury, C. F.
Right arrow Articles by Vyn, T. J.
Agricola
Right arrow Articles by Drury, C. F.
Right arrow Articles by Vyn, T. J.
Related Collections
Right arrow Crop Growth and Development
Right arrow Clover
Right arrow Tillage


HOME HELP FEEDBACK SUBSCRIPTIONS ARCHIVE SEARCH TABLE OF CONTENTS
The SCI Journals Agronomy Journal Crop Science
Journal of Natural Resources
and Life Sciences Education
Vadose Zone Journal
Journal of Plant Registrations Journal of
Environmental Quality
The Plant Genome