|
|
||||||||
a Dep. of Soil and Atmospheric Sci., Univ. of Missouri, Columbia, MO 65211 USA
b USDA-NRCS, Lincoln Univ., Jefferson City, MO USA
hammerr{at}missouri.edu
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Abbreviations: CEC, cation-exchange capacity
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Early soilgeomorphic observations often were conducted in the context of the catena, a concept that describes the areal associations of soils along hydrologic sequences or valley sides (Milne, 1936). Bushnell (1942) divided the soil catena into several components, each characterized by a specific soil with features related to specific erosional or hydrological conditions. The catena model was not preciseit included both uniform and multiple parent materialsand was envisioned both as "a classification grouping" (Bushnell, 1942) and a "unit of mapping convenience" (Milne, 1936). Some catena applications, particularly those which failed to recognize the dynamic nature of soilgeomorphic relationships, were inconsistent or inappropriate (Hall, 1983).
Ruhe (1956) expanded and refined the model by describing relationships among geomorphic surfaces, underlying materials and soils. He related specific soils to specific surfaces in multi-layered glacial drift in Iowa and clearly defined relationships among surface and material ages with expression of certain soil attributes. Acton (1965), working in glacially modified terrain in Canada, related different soils to ice disintegration as affected by different landscape positions. Landscape positions were characterized by differences in length, shape, gradient, and relative position of the individual slope segment. Dan and Yaalon (1968) related specific "pedomorphic forms" to "pedomorphic surfaces," which locally controlled hydrology in Israel. They recognized that soils and relief are "genetically and evolutionarily interdependent" in this setting. Parsons (1978) described soilgeomorphic relationships in Oregon and noted that degree of expression of important soil attributes was a function of age and intensity of weathering, both of which were locally correlated with specific geomorphic surfaces. Pregitzer et al. (1983) documented changes in soils along a topographic gradient, and related these changes to vegetation and nutrient status. These applications all recognized that "landform" includes the underlying materials, and that a hillslope transect may include materials of different ages and sources.
Some studies have investigated hillslope processes, particularly slope length, gradient, and distance from summit, as they affect distributions of soil organic C, clay, and nutrients. These include classic work by Aandahl (1948), Ruhe and Walker (1968), Walker and Ruhe (1968), Kleiss (1970), and Malo et al. (1974). All of these studies revealed that distributions of particular soil attributes vary as functions of geomorphic and hydrologic processes that differentially distribute water, sediments, and dissolved materials. Most studies, however, have used a few "representative pedons" or otherwise relatively small sample sizes. These studies were important in identifying cause-and-effect relationships in soil landscapes; however, they left unanswered the questions related to magnitudes and patterns of variances of soil attributes within specific soils and landforms.
Our hypothesis is that many soil properties vary predictably with landscape position, and that magnitudes of variation should vary among but are somewhat predictable within landforms. Our objective is to use a large data set to test the effect of landscape position on the relationships of soil properties with landforms within a relatively small, loess-mantled upland landscape.
| Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
15%.
|
Sampling
The sampling strategy was to obtain large numbers of samples from each landform while trying to equalize numbers of observations within landforms. Interlocking transects were placed to traverse landforms both parallel and normal to slope gradients (Fig. 1). Transect placement and sampling intervals along transects were determined subjectively to capture the full range of soil variability within landforms (Young et al., 1992). Transects were straight lines, inflected where necessary to conform to landforms. Sampling intervals along transects were 15 m except on ridges, which had smaller areal extent, so sampling density was increased, and ridges were sampled at 7.5-m intervals from multiple, parallel transects 7.5-m apart. A total of 257 pedons was obtained as cores taken with a Giddings hydraulic soil probe (5-cm-diam. tube). Sample depth (120 cm, the length of the sampling tube) contained the taxonomic control sections. All samples were assumed to be independent.
Cores were subdivided for description and laboratory analysis as follows:
20 cm max. A-2 Variable; rest of A horizon B-1 Upper 15 cm of argillic horizon B-2 Next 15-cm depth increment B-3 Next 20-cm depth increment B-4 Next 20-cm depth increment Sampling by genetic horizons is preferable under most conditions, but sampling by depth increments below the A horizon ensured data base uniformity. We wanted to avoid an unbalanced design, which would have resulted from sampling horizons by their thicknesses. The incremental depth sampling approach did not mix unlike materials because changes within the argillic horizons were gradual. The A-1 horizon is roughly equivalent to the Ap horizon. The A-2 horizon was not in all pedons, so its sample size is smaller. Clay films distinguished lower A from upper B horizons. Color and structure were helpful but were not diagnostic. Most B horizons are Bt's or Btg's, although many of the dark B-1 horizons might be considered B/A horizons.
Analyses and Variables
All pedons were classified in the field as being within a ridge, shoulder, or backslope. Surface shapes (convex, plane, or concave both in plan and profile) and slope positions (upper, mid, and lower) were noted for all backslope pedons.
Morphological observations used standard methods (Soil Survey Division Staff, 1993), except for "Fe depletion" and "Femanganese stains and concretions" codes. A "none" category was added to each, and a "gray matrix" category was added to the "Fe depletion" coding.
After morphological observations, all samples were air-dried and ground to pass a 2-mm sieve for the following analyses:
These are the standard characterization analyses for a pedon sampled within the Missouri National Cooperative Soil Survey (NCSS). All analyses were by the University of Missouri Soil Characterization Laboratory except particle-size determination, which was by the modified pipette method (Indorante et al., 1990). Soil pH was in a 1:1 soil solution suspension using an Orion digital ionalyzer/501 pH meter1 (Orion Research, Beverly, MA) with a combination electrode. Total soil C was determined with a Leco CR 12 carbon analyzer1 (Leco Corp., St. Joseph, MI).
Eight of the variables considered in this study are pedon-specific (i.e., are applicable to the pedon as a whole), whereas others are horizon-specific (Table 1) .
|
Most properties were not normally distributed (Young et al., 1999), so the nonparametric Kruskal-Wallis method (Daniel, 1990) was used to detect statistically significant differences among landscape classes. Trial-and-error transformations were not attempted because transformations do not always normalize data effectively (Young et al., 1992). All tests were conducted with SYSTAT (Wilkinson, 1992) software.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Pedogenesis has differed between ridgeshoulder pedons and backslope pedons. Differences in lessivage are reflected in more clay in the argillic horizon in backslope pedons, in contrast to observations by Walker and Ruhe (1968). Leaching and stratigraphic differences are reflected in pH, base saturation and calcium, which indicates that argillic horizons in backslope pedons are more leached in the upper part, but, with increasing depth, are more strongly influenced by calcareous glacial till. Parent materials have also influenced the (clay-free) silt content, which is less in the hillslope sediments of the backslopes than in the loess on the ridges. Melanization and erosional differences between landforms are indicated by higher concentrations of organic C in ridge pedons, which also have thicker epipedons and darker colors deeper into the argillic horizons. Patterns of melanization differ between landforms as well, with increased concentrations of soil profile organic matter in the A-1 horizon of backslope pedons, less with depth, and more accumulation on ped faces relative to pedons on ridges. Gleization is more obvious within backslope pedons, whereas ferrugination is more pronounced within ridgeshoulder pedons. Wider color differences between ped interiors and surfaces within backslope pedons reflects greater redox activity on ped surfaces within backslope pedons. Chemical analyses of Fe and Mn compounds could substantiate these observations.
The CEC7 only partially follows the trend established by more direct measures of clay. Organic C and mineralogy affect CEC. Lesser organic C concentrations in backslope argillic horizons relative to ridge pedons may offset the higher clay content within backslopes.
Magnesium is poorly correlated with other variables. Differences in CA/MG ratios within soil profiles may result from the influence of Ca-rich glacial till with depth in some pedons.
The landscape variables explained relatively little of the substantial chemical and morphological variability within the backslopes. Surface shape appears not to have greatly affected pedogenesis on the backslope. Workers on other landscapes have observed that concave areas are wetter (Anderson and Burt, 1978; Sinai et al., 1981; Boyer et al., 1990), with concomitant differences in drainage class (Troeh, 1964), Fe/Mn ratios (McDaniel et al., 1992), and depth to calcium carbonate (Pennock and de Jong, 1990). Concave areas usually are less eroded or have received hillslope sediments (Kreznor et al., 1989), resulting in thicker A horizons (Pennock et al., 1987; Pennock and de Jong, 1990). Such effects were not observed in this study. Relative youth of the landscape and low relief may be important. Perhaps the subtle convexities and concavities have developed under post-settlement management during the 19th and early 20th centuries.
The few differences detected along the hillslope gradient are related to parent materials and reflect the influence of calcareous glacial till in the lowest slope positions. Other studies have demonstrated systematic changes along slope gradients, including sedimentation processes and hydrologic gradients resulting in increasing C content downslope (Walker and Ruhe, 1968; Kleiss, 1970; Malo et al., 1974; Schimel et al., 1985; Honeycutt et al., 1990; Pennock and de Jong, 1990; Pierson and Mulla, 1990), and particle-size differences (Ruhe and Walker, 1968; Walker and Ruhe, 1968; Walker et al., 1968; Kleiss, 1970; Malo et al., 1974). However, many of these studies were conducted in closed systems. On hillslopes of this study area, pedons on footslope positions are not greatly influenced by deposition, despite the decrease in slope gradient and concave slope profile. Apparently, erosional products are moving out of this open system.
Two hypotheses can be presented to explain pedogenic differences between ridgeshoulder pedons and backslope pedons. One is change in vegetation history. Ridges may have been predominantly prairie, whereas backslopes may have had longer developmental periods under forest. Ridges are drier, more windswept, and more susceptible to fire. Soil differences that support this hypothesis are (i) more abundant silt coats in the A-2 horizons of backslope pedons; (ii) higher organic C concentrations on ridges; (ii) more pronounced clay maxima in the argillic horizons of backslope pedons; and (iv) lower base saturation and lower pH in the upper argillic horizons of backslope pedons.
The vegetation history of this area is thought to have been dynamic (William Schroeder, personal communication, 1993). Presettlement prairie maps show this area as forest at the time of survey (Schroeder, 1981), even though it is referred to as the "Woodlandville Prairie," and the soils are primarily Mollisols. It is possible that the forest encroached between the time that indigenous people were forced to leave and Euroamerican settlement began (Schroeder, personal communication, 1992). Many soils in northcentral Missouri have morphological attributes imparted by both forest and prairie vegetation (Hammer et al., 1994). Climate change during the Pleistocene is highly probable, and vegetation would have changed in response (Ruhe, 1970, 1984). A stable, sustained similar vegetation pattern on prairie ridges and forested backslopes through the Pleistocene seems highly unlikely.
Another hypothesis relates to the interactions among hydrology, landforms, and parent materials. Slope and stratigraphic conditions can create soil water differences (e.g., Afyuni et al., 1993; Boyer et al., 1990; Hanna et al., 1982; McDaniel et al., 1992), and soil variability often results (e.g., Bunting, 1961; Daniels and Gamble, 1967; Alexander, 1986; Rosek and Richardson, 1989; Richardson et al., 1992).
Ridge surfaces in this study site are nearly level, and are mantled with uniform thickness of permeable loess. Water movement is primarily as throughflow. Surface runoff may occur during prolonged or high-intensity spring storms. Ridge pedons presumably desiccate prior to backslopes in the summer, and have more uniform patterns of water or solute movement, and of wetting and drying. Homogeneous slope gradients, surface shapes, and parent materials result in relatively uniform soil properties.
Glacial till is closer to the surface on backslopes, and geomorphic processes have produced hillslope sediments with variable source textures and distributed in variable thicknesses and permeabilities. The underlying, slowly permeable till and the argillic horizon restrict vertical water movement. The combination of slope, differential permeabilities, and runon and seepage from upslope produces variable lateral flow. More complex and variable weathering and erosion processes result. Variability in wetting and drying creates spatially and temporally heterogeneous soil water conditions down the backslopes. Consequently, backslope pedons are more variable than ridge pedons. Backslope argillic horizons have more clay, appear more intensely leached, and have more pronounced and more abundant redoximorphic features. Structural units appear more dense and less permeable, and water-driven pedogenic processes (organic deposition, redox reactions) appear more pronounced on ped surfaces. In summary, backslope pedons have morphological attributes, which indicate preferential water movement through interstitial voids along ped faces. Soils on ridges have more homogenous morphological attributes, suggesting that seasonal distributions of water are more homogeneous temporally and spatially.
The progressive soil survey of Boone County, Missouri, recognizes locally distinct ridge and backslope map units of the Arisburg soil. The units are distinguished by slope and erosion classes. This study indicates that other differences exist, and these differences can be documented in map unit descriptions and interpretive tables. Many Midwestern soil series formed in 1 to 2 m of loess are mapped across different geomorphic surfaces on a wide range of slope gradients. As Major Land Resource Area (MLRA) soil survey updates are undertaken, differences within series among geomorphic surfaces can be sampled for and documented. The importance of hydrology and stratigraphy to soil variability within this study area indicates the need for deep sampling and analyses of Fe and Mn variables in soil survey updates for northern Missouri.
| NOTES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
1 Mention of a specific trade or product name does not necessarily mean the endorsement by the University of Missouri or the exclusion of other products. ![]()
Received for publication September 2, 1996.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
F. E. Rhoton, W. E. Emmerich, D. A. DiCarlo, D. S. McChesney, M. A. Nearing, and J. C. Ritchie Identification of Suspended Sediment Sources Using Soil Characteristics in a Semiarid Watershed Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J., June 18, 2008; 72(4): 1102 - 1112. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
D. B. Myers, N. R. Kitchen, K. A. Sudduth, R. E. Sharp, and R. J. Miles Soybean Root Distribution Related to Claypan Soil Properties and Apparent Soil Electrical Conductivity Crop Sci., July 30, 2007; 47(4): 1498 - 1509. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
F. E. Rhoton, W. E. Emmerich, D. C. Goodrich, S. N. Miller, and D. S. McChesney An Aggregation/Erodibility Index for Soils in a Semiarid Watershed, Southeastern Arizona Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J., May 16, 2007; 71(3): 984 - 992. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. A. Wills, C. L. Burras, and J. A. Sandor Prediction of Soil Organic Carbon Content Using Field and Laboratory Measurements of Soil Color Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J., March 12, 2007; 71(2): 380 - 388. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. D. Tomer, C. A. Cambardella, D. E. James, and T. B. Moorman Surface-Soil Properties and Water Contents across Two Watersheds with Contrasting Tillage Histories Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J., February 27, 2006; 70(2): 620 - 630. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
F. M. Ziadat Analyzing Digital Terrain Attributes to Predict Soil Attributes for a Relatively Large Area Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J., August 25, 2005; 69(5): 1590 - 1599. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| The SCI Journals | Agronomy Journal | Crop Science | |||
| Journal of Natural Resources and Life Sciences Education |
Vadose Zone Journal | ||||
| Journal of Plant Registrations | Journal of Environmental Quality |
The Plant Genome | |||